What should a fuel carrier scorecard measure?
It should measure what a carrier did with the loads you actually offered it, and whether the fuel arrived right. Generic freight scorecards often stop at on-time delivery. A fuel tanker scorecard adds the things that go wrong on a tanker: the wrong compartment, a site the truck cannot get into, a delivery ticket that does not match the load.
If you are a broker offering loads to carriers on behalf of buyers, the scorecard is a short table you can fill from your own records.
What goes on the scorecard, and how do you compute it?
Pick one window, such as the last 90 days, and compute every row per carrier over that same window. Mixing windows makes carriers look better or worse than they are.
| Measure | How to compute it | What to do with it |
|---|---|---|
| Acceptance rate | Loads accepted ÷ offers to that carrier that it answered or let time out | Low and steady: stop offering it first. Low on one lane: that lane is the problem. |
| Response time | Median time from offer to accept (use the median, not the average, so one slow night does not distort it) | Slow responders belong later in your offer order. |
| Timeouts | Offers that expired with no answer ÷ offers | A timeout is worse than a decline: you lost the time and learned nothing. |
| Decline reasons | Count declines by the reason given | Tells you whether to change the load (rate, window) or the carrier. |
| On-time-in-window rate | Deliveries that finished inside the agreed window ÷ deliveries | Decide the window before the load, not after. |
| Product and compartment fit | Loads where the right product went into the right compartment, with no cross-contamination flag ÷ loads | Raise any miss with the carrier. |
| Site access | Deliveries that needed a redo or a wait because the truck could not reach or fit the site ÷ deliveries | Fix the site note first. If it repeats, check the equipment. |
| Ticket and BOL accuracy | Deliveries where the delivery ticket and the bill of lading agree on product and quantity ÷ deliveries | Mismatches are where invoice disputes start. |
| Short or over deliveries | Deliveries where quantity delivered differs from quantity ordered beyond your tolerance ÷ deliveries | Check net versus gross gallons before blaming the driver. |
Keep the on-time row honest. “On time” means inside the window you agreed, measured from a timestamp you trust, such as the time on the delivery ticket. A driver’s text message or a carrier’s own tracking is a weaker source than the ticket.
Why not just use a carrier’s FMCSA safety score?
Because it answers a different question. The FMCSA says its Safety Measurement System “uses data from roadside inspections and crash reports from the last two years” and organizes that data into seven categories it calls BASICs. That is a record of safety behavior, and it is worth checking before you load a carrier at all (we cover that in vetting an external fuel hauling company).
It is not a record of service. A carrier can have a clean inspection history and still ignore half your offers, or show up at the wrong end of the delivery window. The safety record tells you whether to work with the carrier. The scorecard tells you how much work to give it.
How do you read the numbers without fooling yourself?
Look at the count behind each percentage, and compare carriers on the same kind of load.
Say you offered a carrier 20 loads in 90 days. It accepted 15, declined 3 and let 2 time out. That is a 75% acceptance rate and a 10% timeout rate. (These numbers are illustrative, not customer data.) If two of the three declines say the rate was too low, the carrier is telling you its price on those lanes. If all three say the delivery window was too tight, change the window.
Small samples mislead: two accepted loads out of two is 100%, and it tells you almost nothing. Keep decline and silence apart, since a declined offer lets you move to the next carrier right away and a timeout does not.
Score the lane as well as the carrier. One that accepts every load out of one terminal and none out of another has a coverage gap at the second terminal. And write down the window and tolerance rules: ask a carrier to hit a window you never gave it, and every late load becomes an argument.
What do you do with a scorecard once you have it?
Use it to decide who gets offered loads first, and to have a specific conversation with the carriers who miss.
For a broker running an ordered offer list, the scorecard sets the order: high acceptance and quick answers go first. Carriers that rarely answer move down or off. Where you take competing prices through a blind bid, the scorecard is the other half of the decision. The lowest rate from a carrier that times out one time in four is not the cheapest load.
Review monthly. If a carrier has dropped, send it the rows that dropped. If a carrier is strong, that is the evidence for a longer-term arrangement, the kind of contract covered in how to get fuel hauling contracts. A dispatcher who knows these numbers by feel can still use the table to settle disagreements; what a fuel dispatcher does explains why that job sits on top of this data.
Where do the numbers come from?
From wherever you record offers and deliveries. A spreadsheet works for a handful of carriers. Past that, the problem is that offers live in one place, deliveries in another and tickets in a third. That split is the same one described in load board vs. TMS and in our guide to fuel tanker load boards: a board shows you the load, but the scorecard needs the history.
How Energy Connect handles it
On the Network page, and in the waterfall carrier picker in the broker and carrier portals, you see how each connected carrier has answered your offers over the last 90 days: acceptance rate, median time to accept, and timeouts, with the top decline reasons on hover.
Those figures describe the carriers you offered loads to, from your own offers. For the delivery-side rows in the table above, start from your delivery tickets: they carry the timestamps and quantities those rows need.