Portals

Supplier Portal Broker Portal Carrier Portal Customer Portal Mobile app

Integrations

All integrations API docs

Industries

Fuel Propane Lubricants Chemicals Agriculture All industries

Resources

Guides Blog Glossary FAQ Security Features Pricing About Us Login Request a Demo

Home › Rackline › Hauling · Product updates

Who Pays for a Fuel Dry Run?

Who pays for a fuel dry run usually follows the cause: the buyer for a locked gate, the supplier for a closed rack, the carrier for its own fault.

Published
Reading time
5 min read

Key point

A dry run is a fuel trip that ends without unloading. Who pays follows the cause: the buyer usually bears a locked gate or full tank, the supplier a closed rack or missing product, and the carrier its own late or wrong truck. No rule sets this, so write the cause-by-cause terms into the contract.

A dry run is a fuel delivery trip that ends without the truck unloading, and the question is who absorbs the cost.

For a carrier, that means knowing which causes usually fall on whom, and writing the terms down before the first load so you are not arguing about it at the gate.

Who pays for a dry run in trucking?

Who pays is set by the agreement between the parties, not by a regulation. The term is trade usage, and the fee is a commercial term the parties agree, like the freight rate.

What does decide it in practice is cause. A carrier whose agreement covers locked gates is on solid ground billing for one. A carrier that bills a customer for its own late arrival is not. Almost every dispute is really an argument about the cause.

Who pays, by cause?

Match the cause to the party that controlled it. The table shows who typically bears the cost and what the contract should say. “Typically” is the working convention, not a rule; your agreement overrides it.

Cause Who typically bears it What to write into the contract
Customer not ready (nobody on site to receive, no one to sign) Customer Who must be present or reachable, and the window
Site locked or gate closed Customer Gate code or key held by whom, and site hours given with the order
Tank full or no room Customer Whether the ordered quantity was checked against ullage, and by whom
Product not available at the rack Supplier (billed through whoever hired the carrier) That the supplier owns product availability, and what the carrier is paid when the load cannot be lifted
Rack closed, or allocation cut Supplier (billed through whoever hired the carrier) The same, plus notice: how early the carrier must be told
Wrong product ordered Whoever placed the order Who confirms grade against the tank before dispatch
Carrier late, or wrong equipment Carrier That the carrier absorbs it, so the other rows are not blamed for it

Two rows deserve more than a line.

A full tank is usually the customer’s cost, but the order is where it starts. If the order asked for more than the tank could take, the order was the problem. Overfill prevention at the delivery tank covers the checks a driver runs at the drop. Decide in advance who is responsible for the ullage check, because “the customer should have known” is hard to bill.

Rack and allocation causes sit upstream of the carrier. The carrier did not choose the terminal’s hours or the supplier’s allocation. If the supplier hired you, those are the supplier’s to cover. If a broker is in the middle, check whether the cost passes through to you.

How is a dry-run fee priced?

The amount is whatever the parties agree. The three common shapes are a flat fee, a percentage of the freight rate, or hourly time plus mileage. A flat fee is the easiest to invoice. A percentage scales with the haul. Hourly time is closest to the carrier’s real cost but needs the time proved.

Here is a purely illustrative example, not a market rate or customer data. Say you haul 8,000 gallons for a flat $600 and your truck-and-driver cost is $90 an hour. The drive out and back plus the stop took 5 hours, so the wasted trip cost you $450 in time before fuel.

Term Fee Cost recovered Cost not recovered
No dry-run term $0 $0 of $450 $450
Flat fee of $150 $150 $150 of $450 $300
Half the freight rate $300 $300 of $450 $150
Hourly, 5 hours at $90 $450 $450 of $450 $0

A flat fee set below your real cost still leaves you out of pocket on every dry run, and having no term leaves you absorbing all of it. Price the term against your own hourly cost.

How does this differ from detention?

Detention is the charge for a truck that waits; a dry run is the charge for a truck that leaves without unloading. They overlap when a driver waits at a locked gate and then leaves. Keep them as separate terms, each with its own trigger, so one wait is not billed twice. Detention pay in fuel trucking covers free time and hourly rates. The DOT Office of Inspector General found in 2018 that accurate industrywide data on driver detention did not exist, which is a good reason to price both terms from your own costs rather than an assumed market rate.

How do you prove what caused the dry run?

Record the cause at the site, while it happens. Note the time you arrived, who you spoke to, what stopped the unload, and take a photo of a locked gate or a tank gauge. A dry run produces no delivered quantity, so there is no delivery ticket to settle the dispute the way there is on a completed drop. Your own record is the evidence, and a reason on the record is what separates “customer’s gate was locked” from “driver could not get in”.

What terms belong in the agreement?

Put the dry-run term in the same place as your freight rate, before the load. The terms that matter:

  • Which causes trigger a charge, using the table above as the starting list
  • How the charge is priced, and whether it is separate from demurrage or detention
  • What counts as proof of cause, and how fast it must be reported
  • How much notice a customer or supplier must give to cancel or reschedule without a charge
  • Who pays when the cause is disputed or shared

How to get fuel hauling contracts covers the other terms to agree up front. Where the customer’s own cancellation or change is the cause, the earlier the carrier hears, the less the trip costs.

How Energy Connect handles it

On a single-stop load, a carrier can report in the carrier portal that it arrived but couldn’t deliver, with a reason. The poster is notified and can convert the load to a dry run or reschedule it. That puts the cause on the load record at the time of the attempt.

On an accepted single-stop load that has not been picked up, the hauler can propose a new delivery date, delivery window or quantity, and the poster approves or declines it. That gives a changed date or quantity a record before the truck rolls.

Sources

  1. Estimates Show Commercial Driver Detention Increases Crash Risks and Costs, but Current Data Limit Further Analysis (DOT OIG, 2018)oig.dot.gov